In partnership with
Starting a newsletter on beehiiv feels exciting… until you realize something uncomfortable.
You hit “publish.”
You refresh the dashboard.
And nothing happens.
No visitors.
No subscribers.
Just silence.
I’ve been there. Most beehiiv creators have.
The good news? Growing a newsletter isn’t complicated. It’s just repeatable work done the right way.
Let’s break it down so anyone can follow along.
But first, a word from today’s sponsor: 👇
Turn AI into Your Income Engine
Ready to transform artificial intelligence from a buzzword into your personal revenue generator?
HubSpot’s groundbreaking guide "200+ AI-Powered Income Ideas" is your gateway to financial innovation in the digital age.
Inside you'll discover:
A curated collection of 200+ profitable opportunities spanning content creation, e-commerce, gaming, and emerging digital markets—each vetted for real-world potential
Step-by-step implementation guides designed for beginners, making AI accessible regardless of your technical background
Cutting-edge strategies aligned with current market trends, ensuring your ventures stay ahead of the curve
Download your guide today and unlock a future where artificial intelligence powers your success. Your next income stream is waiting.
🚨 Ok, back to the main topic. 🚨
Why Getting Traffic to Your beehiiv Newsletter Feels Hard (At First)
Most new creators believe this lie:
“If my writing is good, people will find it.”
They won’t.
Not because your writing is bad, but because the internet doesn’t work that way.
When I first started, I thought publishing consistently was enough. I waited for discovery. I waited for shares. I waited for “organic growth.”
Nothing moved.
Growth started only when I stopped waiting and started actively bringing people to my newsletter.
Image Credit: Sell Ideas Analytics
First Things First: Make Your Newsletter Worth Subscribing To
Before worrying about traffic, ask one simple question:
Why should someone subscribe?
Not:
“Because I write every week”
“Because I share my thoughts”
“Because I’m passionate”
But:
What problem do you help with?
What does the reader gain?
Example for a new beehiiv creator
Bad:
“Weekly thoughts on business and life.”
Better:
“Simple lessons to help beginners build and sell online without burning out.”
Clear beats clever every time.
If someone can’t understand your newsletter in 5 seconds, they won’t subscribe.
Optimize Your beehiiv Landing Page (Small Changes, Big Impact)
Your beehiiv landing page has one job:
Turn visitors into subscribers.
That’s it.
What actually works
One clear headline
One short explanation
One call to action
Example
Instead of:
“Join my newsletter where I share insights, experiences, and strategies.”
Try:
“I write short emails showing beginners how to grow an online audience without posting all day.”
Simple. Direct. Human.
Also, remove distractions. No long paragraphs. No life story. People scroll fast.
Here’s an example I’ve posted on my Threads 👇
Posting your newsletter link everywhere doesn’t work.
Talking about ideas from your newsletter does.
What most beginners do
Post: “New newsletter out! Link in bio.”
Repeat.
Get ignored.
What works better
Share one useful idea from your newsletter.
Then let curiosity do the work.
Example for X / Threads / LinkedIn
Post:
“One mistake new creators make: they wait for traffic instead of borrowing it. I explained how I fixed this in today’s newsletter.”
You’re not begging.
You’re inviting.
That’s a huge difference.
Here’s what happened when you provide value. 👇
Turn Your Old Content Into New Subscribers
If you’ve posted online before, you already have assets.
Use them.
Simple ways new beehiiv creators can do this
Add your beehiiv link to:
Your bio
Pinned posts
Comment replies
Update old posts with:
“I write more about this in my newsletter.”
You don’t need new content every day.
You need better distribution of what you already have.
Here’s an example of how I pinned my last post on X. 👇
Use beehiiv’s Built-In Growth Tools (Without Overthinking)
beehiiv gives you tools most beginners ignore.
That’s a mistake.
Start with these
Recommendations: Recommend newsletters you actually read. Many will recommend you back.
Boosts: Enable them and let beehiiv help you get subscribers automatically.
Referral program: Keep rewards simple. Early on, even a shoutout works. (at the end of this post I’ve add my referral program link as an example)
Don’t try to use everything at once.
Pick one. Set it up. Move on.
Collaborate With Other Creators (Even If You’re Small)
You don’t need a big audience to collaborate.
You need the right audience.
Example for beginners
If you have 100 subscribers and someone else has 200:
That’s not “too small.”
That’s perfect.
You can:
Recommend each other’s newsletters
Do a simple shoutout swap
Mention each other in one issue
Audience fit matters more than numbers.
Here’s an example: 👇
Stay Consistent When Growth Feels Slow
Here’s the truth most people don’t say:
Newsletter growth is boring.
Some weeks:
You’ll get 1 subscriber.
Sometimes zero.
That’s normal.
Most creators quit not because it doesn’t work, but because it doesn’t work fast.
Consistency is the real advantage.
Here’s an example: 👇
A Simple Weekly Routine for New beehiiv Creators
You don’t need hours a day.
Here’s a realistic routine:
Daily (10–15 minutes)
Reply to posts in your niche
Share one useful idea
Weekly
Send two or three valuable newsletters
Promote it once or twice
Reach out to one creator for a collaboration
That’s enough.
Do it for 3 months and you’ll be ahead of 90% of people.
RELATED
Final Thoughts: Growth Is Boring, But It Works
There’s no secret hack.
Just:
Clear positioning
Simple writing
Consistent promotion
Patience
If you focus on helping real people instead of chasing numbers, the numbers follow.
One action to take today
Rewrite your beehiiv landing page headline so a stranger instantly understands:
Who it’s for
What they get
Why it matters
That alone can change everything.
If this helped you, I’d really appreciate it if you could recommend Sell Ideas to someone who’s trying to get paid for their ideas.
You don’t need to grow louder. You just need to grow clearer.
-Azhar (Founder, Sell Ideas)
Want to support my work? You can buy me a coffee here ☕
Every Creator Needs His Platform.
I run everything on Beehiiv. It’s built for creators who move fast and want full control of their growth.
Use my link and get 30 days free + 20% OFF for 3 months.
You start your journey, and I earn 50% commission for 12 months.
It’s a Mutual Win.
NOTE: Get ‘Sell Ideas’ latest newsletter every week (sometimes daily). Can't find it? Check your spam or promotions folder, then drag it to your main inbox for future reference.
Doing this a few times should ensure that our emails consistently reach your inbox.
